Find My Breed

Breed comparison

Border Collie vs Australian Shepherd

The short answer

The Border Collie and the Australian Shepherd are 93% alike across our 15 traits. Where they differ most:

  • 01The Border Collie is a smaller dog than the Australian Shepherd (5/10 vs 6/10).
  • 02The Border Collie has more energy than the Australian Shepherd (10/10 vs 9/10).
  • 03The Border Collie is easier to train than the Australian Shepherd (10/10 vs 9/10).

Choose the Border Collie if you want

  • a smaller size that's easier to carry and house
  • more energy for long walks and sport
  • quicker learning and easier training

Choose the Australian Shepherd if you want

  • a larger, more substantial build
  • a calmer, lower-energy routine
  • a more independent-minded character

Quick facts

Border CollieAustralian Shepherd
Weight31–55 lb (14–25 kg)40–64 lb (18–29 kg)
Height18–22 in (46–56 cm)18–23 in (46–58 cm)
Life expectancy12–15 years12–15 years
OriginUnited KingdomUnited States

All 15 traits side by side

Trait profileAB
Size5/106/10
Energy level10/109/10
Trainability10/109/10
Shedding7/108/10
Barking5/105/10
Friendliness7/107/10
Good with kids7/108/10
Good with other pets6/107/10
Alone tolerance3/104/10
Grooming needs5/106/10
Drool2/102/10
Health robustness8/107/10
Allergy-friendly1/101/10
Longevity8/107/10
Affordability6/105/10

Border Collie

+ Strengths

  • Off-the-charts trainability
  • Healthy and long-lived
  • Excels at dog sports

− Things to consider

  • Needs a serious job or sport
  • Can nip and herd children
  • Overthinks everything
Profile →

Australian Shepherd

+ Strengths

  • Stunning merle coats
  • Highly trainable
  • Devoted family member

− Things to consider

  • Heavy shedder
  • High exercise + mental needs
  • Can be vocal and herd-y
Profile →

Questions people ask

Q01Which is better, the Border Collie or the Australian Shepherd?
Neither is better overall — it depends on your home. The Border Collie suits you if you want a smaller size that's easier to carry and house, more energy for long walks and sport, and quicker learning and easier training. The Australian Shepherd suits you if you want a larger, more substantial build, a calmer, lower-energy routine, and a more independent-minded character.
Q02What is the main difference between the Border Collie and the Australian Shepherd?
The Border Collie is a smaller dog than the Australian Shepherd (5/10 vs 6/10).

Still unsure?

Get a match based on your own life

The 2-minute quiz weighs all 15 traits against your home, schedule and experience.

Take the quiz

More comparisons