How we score breeds and match you
The 15 traits and the 0–10 scale
Every dog and cat breed has a profile of 15 named traits. Eleven are shared by both species: size, energy, shedding, grooming needs, friendliness, how well the breed gets on with children and with other pets, health robustness, allergy-friendliness, longevity and affordability. The other four are species-specific: trainability, barking, alone tolerance and drool for dogs; affection, vocalness, independence and intelligence for cats.
Each trait is scored from 0 to 10, with 5 in the middle, and a higher number always means more of that trait. For most traits that is neither good nor bad: more energy or a bigger size suits some homes and not others. A few traits are defined so that a higher score is the easier option: allergy-friendliness, health robustness, longevity, affordability (higher means cheaper to keep), alone tolerance for dogs and independence for cats (higher means the animal copes better on its own).
Scores are relative. A shedding score of 9 means the breed sheds more than almost every other breed we cover, not that it crosses some absolute line. The tables below explain what each trait measures and what a low (0–2) or high (8–10) score looks like in daily life.
Where the scores come from
Our editors compile the scores from official breed standards and widely used breed references: the American Kennel Club (AKC), The Royal Kennel Club in the UK and the Fédération Cynologique Internationale (FCI) for dogs, and The Cat Fanciers' Association (CFA) and The International Cat Association (TICA) for cats. These sources mostly describe traits in words — high exercise needs, say, or a heavy seasonal moult — and we translate those descriptions into numbers.
We then calibrate the breeds against each other, trait by trait, so that the same number means roughly the same thing across the whole list: the Border Collie and the Siberian Husky sit at the top of the energy scale, the English Bulldog near the bottom. New breeds are placed on the same scales rather than scored in isolation.
The scores are our editorial synthesis, not an official rating from any of these organisations, and they are not veterinary advice. They describe the typical tendencies of a breed, not guarantees about any individual animal. Research supports both halves of that statement: behavioural differences between breeds are real and partly heritable in dogs and in cats, yet a large study that combined owner surveys of more than 18,000 dogs with DNA data found that breed explained only about 9% of the variation in behaviour between individual dogs.
How the quiz turns your answers into matches
Each quiz has 8 core questions and 12 optional ones that refine the result. Every answer sets a target value on one or more traits, plus a weight that says how much that trait should count. Choosing “Small apartment, no outdoor space” in the dog quiz, for example, aims for a small dog (size 2) with fairly low energy (4) and little barking (3), and gives size the most weight. Answers such as “No preference” set no target, so that trait simply stays out of your calculation.
When several answers touch the same trait, they are combined: the target becomes their weighted average and the weights add up, so a trait that comes up in several of your answers counts for more.
For each breed, we then measure how far its scores sit from your targets. On every trait that has a target, we take the gap — a target of 2 and a breed score of 7 is a gap of 5 — multiply it by that trait's weight, and add the results together. This is called a weighted Manhattan distance. The breeds with the smallest distance rank highest, and the result page shows your top three.
The match percentage turns that distance into a score out of 100: match % = 100 × (1 − distance ÷ maximum distance), rounded to a whole number. The maximum distance is the sum of your weights multiplied by 10, as if a breed missed every target by the full width of the scale, so 100% means a breed hits every one of your targets exactly. Because the percentage depends on your answers, compare percentages within your own results rather than with other people's.
We deliberately use this simple method instead of a machine-learning model or an AI chatbot. Every result can be traced back to published trait scores and the weights of your answers, the same answers always produce the same ranking, and nothing is hidden in a black box. If a match looks wrong, it can be traced to specific scores and weights, which makes errors easy to find and fix.
The calculation runs in your browser. There is no sign-up and no database of answers: your answers are encoded in the result page's link so you can share or revisit it.
- The “Is this breed right for you?” check on each breed page uses the same formula to score that one breed against your answers, and shows where the biggest gaps are.
- The “similar breeds” on each breed page use the same distance, with all 15 traits weighted equally.
How our “best breeds for…” lists work
Each list — for example, the best dogs for apartments or the best cats for families with kids — is built from the same trait scores in two steps, set out below.
Treat a list as a starting point rather than a verdict: a breed just outside a threshold may still suit you, which is why the quiz itself uses distances instead of cut-offs.
- Hard requirements: a breed must pass every threshold to qualify. For apartments, a dog must score 5 or lower for size and 7 or lower for both energy and barking; a breed that misses any one of these is left out, however well it scores elsewhere.
- Weighted ranking: qualifying breeds get a fit score from 0 to 10, a weighted average of the traits that matter for that list. Where less is better, such as barking for apartments, the score is flipped (10 minus the breed's score), so a higher fit always means a better match.
- Up to eight breeds are shown per list, and ties are broken by breed popularity.
- Each list page shows its requirements and weights, and names popular breeds that missed the cut along with the requirement they failed.
What the scores can't tell you
Breed is only part of the picture. Individual genetics, early socialisation, training, age and health all shape how an animal behaves, and dogs and cats vary widely within every breed. Use the scores to narrow down your options, not to predict what a particular puppy or kitten will be like.
We encourage adoption first. Shelters and breed-specific rescues care for many purebred and mixed-breed dogs and cats, and their staff and foster carers can tell you how a particular animal behaves with children, with other pets and when left alone — something no breed score can do.
- Individual variation: an outgoing breed can produce a shy dog, and a famously vocal breed a quiet cat.
- Mixed breeds: we score pedigree breeds only. A mixed-breed dog or cat may take after either parent breed, a blend of both or neither, so averaging two profiles is only a rough guide.
- Health varies by line: health robustness reflects common breed-related problems, not the health of a particular litter. The parents' health screening and history, and good veterinary care, make a big difference.
- Rescue animals: a dog or cat from a shelter arrives with its own history, and its current temperament matters far more than its breed label.
- Allergies: no dog or cat is completely allergen-free. Spend time with the breed — ideally with the individual animal — before committing.
- Costs and lifespans: these scores are relative guides, not price quotes or life-expectancy figures, and real costs vary a lot from country to country.
Editorial independence
The site is free to use and funded by advertising through Google AdSense. Ads are selected and served by Google; advertisers have no say in our content, and ads never influence scores, quiz results or list rankings.
We use no affiliate links and accept no payments from breeders or anyone else to feature or rank a breed. Every result comes from the formulas described on this page, applied in the same way to every breed.
Corrections and feedback
If you think a score is wrong, or something on a breed page doesn't match your experience, please let us know using the contact details on the About page. It helps to name the breed and the trait and, if you can, to point to a source such as a breed standard.
We check reports against our sources, correct confirmed errors and update the date on this page whenever the scores or methods change.
Dogs
- Size
Adult body size and weight, from toy breeds to giant breeds.
0–2 A toy or small dog, well under 12 kg, that is easy to carry and fits comfortably in a small home.·8–10 A large or giant dog, often 30 kg or more, that needs room indoors, a big car and a bigger food budget.
- Energy level
How much daily exercise and activity the breed needs to stay content.
0–2 Happy with short daily walks and plenty of naps; suits a quieter routine.·8–10 Needs vigorous exercise and mental work every day, often well over an hour, or it may become restless or destructive.
- Trainability
How readily the breed learns and follows cues, reflecting its typical eagerness to work with people.
0–2 Independent-minded; training takes patience, consistency and realistic expectations.·8–10 Picks up new cues quickly and enjoys training; a natural for obedience and dog sports.
- Shedding
How much hair the dog typically drops around the home, including seasonal moults.
0–2 Leaves little or no hair on floors, furniture and clothes.·8–10 Sheds heavily, often with big seasonal moults; expect frequent vacuuming and brushing.
- Barking
How often the breed tends to bark, howl or vocalise to alert.
0–2 Rarely barks; usually quiet indoors.·8–10 Barks readily at noises, visitors and passers-by; may need training to suit close neighbours.
- Friendliness
How warmly the breed tends to greet people, including strangers.
0–2 Reserved or aloof with strangers and slow to warm up to new people.·8–10 Greets nearly everyone as a friend; not a natural guard dog.
- Good with kids
How well the breed typically tolerates the noise, handling and unpredictability of children.
0–2 Better suited to adult homes or families with older, dog-savvy children.·8–10 Typically patient and gentle with children, though young children and dogs should always be supervised.
- Good with other pets
How well the breed usually gets along with other dogs, cats and small animals.
0–2 May chase cats and small animals or clash with other dogs; often happiest as an only pet.·8–10 Usually accepts other dogs and cats readily, especially when raised with them.
- Alone tolerance
How well the breed copes with being left alone for a few hours.
0–2 Prone to stress, barking or chewing when left alone; best with someone home most of the day.·8–10 Usually settles calmly for several hours alone once its exercise needs are met.
- Grooming needs
How much brushing, bathing, trimming and professional grooming the coat needs.
0–2 An occasional brush and bath is enough.·8–10 Needs brushing several times a week or daily, plus regular professional clipping, which adds time and cost.
- Drool
How much the breed drools or slobbers.
0–2 Mouth stays mostly dry.·8–10 Drools heavily, especially after eating or drinking; keep a towel handy.
- Health robustness
How free the breed generally is from common inherited health problems, and how hardy it tends to be.
0–2 Prone to breed-related problems such as breathing, joint or heart conditions; budget for vet care and look for health-screened parents.·8–10 Generally hardy, with relatively few breed-typical health problems.
- Allergy-friendly
How suitable the breed tends to be for people with dog allergies, mainly reflecting coat type and shedding. No dog is completely allergen-free.
0–2 Sheds hair and dander freely; a poor choice if anyone at home has dog allergies.·8–10 A low-shedding coat that many people with mild allergies tolerate better, though reactions vary from person to person.
- Longevity
Typical lifespan of the breed compared with other breeds.
0–2 Shorter-lived; many breeds in this range average under 10 years.·8–10 Often lives into the mid-teens or beyond.
- Affordability
How cheap the breed typically is to keep: food, routine vet care, grooming and likely health costs. A higher score means cheaper.
0–2 Expensive to keep, through large food bills, frequent professional grooming or higher expected vet costs.·8–10 Relatively inexpensive to feed, groom and keep healthy.
Cats
- Size
Adult body size and weight, from petite cats to large breeds such as the Maine Coon.
0–2 A small, light cat that needs little space.·8–10 A large, heavy cat that needs sturdy cat trees and a large litter tray.
- Energy level
How much play and activity the breed wants each day.
0–2 Mellow and content to lounge; short play sessions are enough.·8–10 Tireless and curious; needs daily interactive play, climbing space and toys to avoid boredom.
- Affection
How much the cat seeks physical closeness, laps and attention from its people.
0–2 Affectionate on its own terms; prefers sitting near you to being held.·8–10 A lap cat that follows you from room to room and asks for attention often.
- Vocalness
How often and how loudly the breed meows, chirps or “talks”.
0–2 Quiet; rarely meows unless it needs something.·8–10 Very talkative; comments on everything and loudly asks for attention or food.
- Shedding
How much loose hair the cat leaves around the home.
0–2 Very little loose hair, as in hairless or very short, fine-coated breeds.·8–10 Sheds a lot, especially during seasonal moults; expect regular vacuuming and brushing.
- Grooming needs
How much brushing, bathing or skin care the breed needs.
0–2 Largely self-maintaining; an occasional brush is enough.·8–10 Needs daily brushing to prevent mats or, for hairless breeds, regular baths and skin care.
- Friendliness
How sociable the breed is with visitors and new people.
0–2 Shy with strangers; may hide when guests arrive.·8–10 Greets visitors like a host and enjoys a busy household.
- Good with kids
How well the breed tolerates children's handling, noise and play.
0–2 Better suited to a calm, adult household.·8–10 Patient and tolerant with respectful children.
- Good with other pets
How readily the breed accepts other cats and dogs.
0–2 Prefers to be the only pet.·8–10 Usually settles in well with other cats and cat-friendly dogs after a careful introduction.
- Independence
How well the cat copes with time alone; a higher score means it manages better on its own.
0–2 Wants company most of the day and may become stressed or demanding when left alone.·8–10 Content to entertain itself while you're out at work.
- Intelligence
How quickly the breed learns, solves problems and seeks mental stimulation.
0–2 Easy-going and content with simple routines.·8–10 Quick to learn tricks and solve problems; needs puzzle feeders and games to stay out of mischief.
- Health robustness
How free the breed generally is from common inherited health problems, and how hardy it tends to be.
0–2 Prone to breed-related problems such as breathing, joint or kidney conditions; ask about the parents' health screening.·8–10 Generally hardy, with relatively few breed-typical health problems.
- Allergy-friendly
Relative suitability for people with cat allergies. No cat breed is truly hypoallergenic: the main cat allergen comes from saliva and skin glands rather than fur, so cat scores on this trait stay low to moderate.
0–2 A poor choice if anyone at home has cat allergies.·8–10 We score no cat breed this high, because even the most allergy-friendly cats still produce allergens.
- Longevity
Typical lifespan of the breed compared with other breeds.
0–2 Shorter-lived than most cat breeds.·8–10 Often lives well past 15, sometimes close to 20.
- Affordability
How affordable the breed typically is to get and keep: purchase or adoption price, food, routine vet care and likely health costs. A higher score means cheaper.
0–2 Expensive, through a high purchase price or above-average care and vet costs.·8–10 Relatively inexpensive to get and keep.
Sources
- American Kennel Club (AKC) — Dog breeds
- The Royal Kennel Club — Breed standards
- Fédération Cynologique Internationale (FCI) — Breeds nomenclature
- The Cat Fanciers' Association (CFA) — Breeds
- The International Cat Association (TICA) — Breeds
- Morrill, K. et al. (2022). Ancestry-inclusive dog genomics challenges popular breed stereotypes. Science 376, eabk0639
- MacLean, E. L. et al. (2019). Highly heritable and functionally relevant breed differences in dog behaviour. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 286, 20190716
- Salonen, M. et al. (2019). Breed differences of heritable behaviour traits in cats. Scientific Reports 9, 7949