Find My Breed

Breed comparison

British Shorthair vs American Shorthair

The short answer

The British Shorthair and the American Shorthair are 91% alike across our 15 traits. Where they differ most:

  • 01The British Shorthair is calmer and less active than the American Shorthair (3/10 vs 5/10).
  • 02The British Shorthair is more expensive to get and keep than the American Shorthair (4/10 vs 6/10).
  • 03The British Shorthair is less cuddly than the American Shorthair and more affectionate on its own terms (5/10 vs 6/10).

Choose the British Shorthair if you want

  • a mellower, more relaxed routine
  • a breed you're happy to spend more on
  • a more hands-off, less clingy bond

Choose the American Shorthair if you want

  • more energy for long play sessions
  • lower costs to get and keep
  • more cuddles and lap time

Quick facts

British ShorthairAmerican Shorthair
Weight7–17 lb (3–7.5 kg)6–15 lb (2.5–7 kg)
Life expectancy14–20 years15–20 years
OriginUnited KingdomUnited States

All 15 traits side by side

Trait profileAB
Size6/106/10
Energy level3/105/10
Affection5/106/10
Vocalness2/103/10
Shedding7/106/10
Grooming needs4/103/10
Friendliness6/107/10
Good with kids8/108/10
Good with other pets7/108/10
Independence7/106/10
Intelligence5/106/10
Health robustness7/108/10
Allergy-friendly2/102/10
Longevity7/107/10
Affordability4/106/10

British Shorthair

+ Strengths

  • Calm, quiet, and rarely destructive
  • Tolerates time alone well
  • Gentle and patient with children

− Things to consider

  • Heavy shedding, especially in spring
  • Prone to obesity — watch food portions
  • Not a lap cat; dislikes being carried
Profile →

American Shorthair

+ Strengths

  • Exceptionally healthy and hardy
  • Easygoing with kids, pets, and strangers
  • Low grooming, short low-maintenance coat

− Things to consider

  • Can gain weight if overfed and under-played
  • Moderate seasonal shedding
  • Independent streak — not overly clingy
Profile →

Questions people ask

Q01Which is better, the British Shorthair or the American Shorthair?
Neither is better overall — it depends on your home. The British Shorthair suits you if you want a mellower, more relaxed routine, a breed you're happy to spend more on, and a more hands-off, less clingy bond. The American Shorthair suits you if you want more energy for long play sessions, lower costs to get and keep, and more cuddles and lap time.
Q02What is the main difference between the British Shorthair and the American Shorthair?
The British Shorthair is calmer and less active than the American Shorthair (3/10 vs 5/10).

Still unsure?

Get a match based on your own life

The 2-minute quiz weighs all 15 traits against your home, schedule and experience.

Take the quiz

More comparisons